Actual 5/7/1957 Gil McDougald Hit Baseball that struck Herb Score in the Face

The Legendary Herb Score Baseball: A Piece of Baseball History

An Unforgettable Moment in Baseball

On the fateful night of May 7, 1957, the baseball world witnessed a harrowing incident that would forever be etched in the annals of sports history. Herb Score, a promising pitcher for the Cleveland Indians, faced the New York Yankees in a game that took a dramatic turn. A line drive off the bat of Gil McDougald struck Score in the face, breaking numerous bones and leaving him bloodied on the field. This tragic event not only impacted Score’s career but also left a lasting impression on the baseball community.

The Baseball with a Story

This particular baseball, an OAL Harridge, holds immense historical significance as it was the very ball that struck Herb Score. Presented to us directly from the wife of Mike Garcia, Score’s teammate, this artifact comes with impeccable provenance. Gerda Garcia has provided a handwritten letter of provenance, dated August 1, 2009, which states, in part, “The night of May 7, 1957, Mike brought home this ball and said ‘Put this ball away. This is the ball that hit Herb in the eye. Herb did not want the ball.’ The ball has been in my possession from that date until the present.”

Why This Baseball Matters

• Historical Significance: Represents a pivotal moment in baseball history, marking a turning point in Herb Score’s career.
• Unique Provenance: Directly linked to Mike Garcia, Score’s teammate, adding authenticity and a personal touch to its history.
• Condition and Story: The ball bears the inscription “Ball that hit Herb Score on eye Pitching against Yankees May 1957 Night Game 1st inning” in blue ink, further cementing its place in baseball lore.

Herb Score’s Legacy

Despite the severity of his injuries, Herb Score remarkably recovered his 20/20 vision, although he missed the remainder of the 1957 season. Many believe that the fear of being hit again altered his pitching motion, leading to a decline in velocity and further injuries. Nevertheless, Score’s resilience saw him pitch the full 1959 season and parts of the following three seasons before retiring. His legacy is further honored by Mickey Mantle, who regarded Score as the toughest American League left-handed pitcher he faced.

This baseball is not just a piece of sports memorabilia; it is a testament to the courage and determination of Herb Score. It stands as a symbol of a moment that changed the trajectory of a promising career and serves as a poignant reminder of the unpredictable nature of sports. For those interested in acquiring a piece of baseball history, this artifact is a rare and valuable addition to any baseball memorabilia collection.

Explore more about this extraordinary piece and other sports memorabilia at Grey Flannel Auctions. Whether you’re looking to consign sports memorabilia or sell your own pieces, our platform offers unparalleled opportunities for collectors and enthusiasts alike.

* This text was generated from the original auction listing.