1928 Arnold Rothstein “AR” Monogrammed Silver Cigarette Case

The Enigmatic Arnold Rothstein Cigarette Case

A Glimpse into the Underworld

Step into the shadowy world of early 20th-century New York with an artifact that whispers tales of intrigue and infamy. This approximately 3” x 3.5” silver cigarette case, engraved with the initials “AR,” is a tangible connection to Arnold Rothstein, the notorious kingpin of the Jewish mob. Rothstein, a figure shrouded in mystery and legend, is most famously associated with the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series, known as the “Black Sox Scandal.” This cigarette case, in NM-MNT condition, offers a rare glimpse into the life of a man whose influence extended far beyond the baseball diamond.

A Historical Artifact with a Unique Provenance

Accompanied by a Letter of Authenticity from the Brian Feehan Estate, this cigarette case carries a story as compelling as Rothstein himself. The letter states, “My grandfather Joseph Feehan was a detective at the time for the city of New York and was first to arrive at Mr. Rothstein’s shooting…He picked it [cigarette case] up and put it in his pocket with the intention of returning the case to him when he was released from the hospital.” This provenance adds a layer of intrigue and authenticity, making it a coveted piece for collectors of sports memorabilia and historical artifacts alike.

Why This Cigarette Case Matters

• Historical Significance: Linked to Arnold Rothstein, a pivotal figure in American organized crime history.
• Unique Provenance: Accompanied by a letter from the Brian Feehan Estate, detailing its connection to Rothstein’s shooting.
• Condition and Craftsmanship: The case is in NM-MNT condition, showcasing exquisite craftsmanship and enduring elegance.

An Artifact of Intrigue and Elegance

This cigarette case is not merely a piece of silver; it is a fragment of history, a relic from a time when the lines between sports, crime, and society were blurred. It stands as a testament to the complex legacy of Arnold Rothstein, a man whose influence reached into the very fabric of American culture. For collectors and enthusiasts, this case is an opportunity to own a piece of the past, a tangible link to a story that continues to captivate and intrigue.

Explore more about such fascinating artifacts and consider adding to your collection by visiting our consignment page or browse through our baseball memorabilia auctions to discover other unique items. Whether you are looking to sell sports memorabilia or simply appraise your treasures, Grey Flannel Auctions is your trusted partner in the world of sports collectibles.

* This text was generated from the original auction listing.